Existence Of Agreement Was Not An Issue To Delegate To Arbitrator.
Fiona Trinity sued Life Insurance Company of North America and individuals (LINA parties) for employment-related claims. The LINA Parties moved unsuccessfully to compel arbitration in the trial court, and the Court of Appeal affirmed. The LINA parties could not establish the existence of an agreement to arbitrate, and even if they could, the agreement would have been unconscionable. Trinity v. Life Insurance Company of America et al., B312302 (2/7 5/23/22) (Perluss, Segal, Feuer).
The defendant's PMK had testified as to the contract procedure, explaining that once the employee had clicked on a link indicating he or she had read an online employee handbook, which included an arbitration agreement, they would receive an email confirming their assent to the terms of the handbook. The problem was that the employer could not produce the automatically generated receipt and did not know how to retrieve it, and the employee did not remember reading or agreeing to the handbook.
While issues of arbitrability were delegated to the arbitrator here, whether there is an agreement to arbitrate in the first place is an issue for the judge to decide. The issue of arbitrability cannot be delegated under the terms of a nonexistent agreement.
COMMENT: In the 21st century, there is still at least one advantage to the use of a paper document with an inked signature. Electronic signing is permissible, but then one must carefully follow procedure and have a good storage and retrieval system for electronic data.
Comments