Stephnie Trujillo v. J-M Manufacturing Company, Inc., B327111 (2/8 12/2/24) (Stratton, Grimes, Wiley).
This case involves an employer's obligation to make timely payment to the arbitrator, as required by statute, or face the prospect of losing the right to arbitrate. The facts are unusual.
Stephnie Trujillo filed a complaint against her former employer, J-M Manufacturing Company (JMM), and four coworkers alleging sexual/gender discrimination, harassment, retaliation, and other claims. The parties entered into a post-dispute arbitration stipulation, which was court-approved. JMM made timely payments to the arbitrator for over a year but failed to pay an invoice within the required 30-day grace period under California Code of Civil Procedure section 1281.98. Despite promptly paying the overdue amount upon notice, Trujillo sought to withdraw from arbitration, citing JMM’s late payment as a material breach under section 1281.98.
The trial court granted Trujillo’s motion to withdraw. On appeal, JMM argued section 1281.98 did not apply because the arbitration was based on a post-dispute stipulation, not a pre-dispute agreement, and JMM was not the “drafting party” as defined in the statute.
The Court of Appeal agreed with JMM, holding section 1281.98 applies exclusively to pre-dispute arbitration agreements where the employer or business is the drafting party. Since the arbitration arose from a negotiated post-dispute stipulation primarily drafted by Trujillo, the statute was inapplicable. The appellate court reversed the trial court’s order and directed reinstatement of arbitration proceedings.
Edgar Gonzalez v. Nowhere Beverly Hills LLC et al., B328959 (2/1 12/3/24) (Kline, Rothschild, Bendix).
In this case, an employee finds himself required by equitable estoppel to arbitrate.
Edgar Gonzalez, a former employee of Nowhere Santa Monica (one of the 10 Nowhere entities operating Erewhon markets in Los Angeles), filed a lawsuit alleging violations of California labor laws, including unpaid wages and failure to provide required breaks. Gonzalez signed an employment agreement with Nowhere Santa Monica that included an arbitration clause. However, his claims were against all 10 Nowhere entities, which he alleged were joint employers.
The trial court compelled arbitration against Nowhere Santa Monica but denied the motion for the other entities, ruling there was no evidence to show equitable estoppel applied. Gonzalez later dismissed his claims against Nowhere Santa Monica.
On appeal, the court reversed the trial court's decision, holding that Gonzalez’s claims against the non-Santa Monica entities were so intertwined with his employment agreement that he could not avoid arbitration. The appellate court found Gonzalez equitably estopped from denying arbitration with the non-signatory entities because his joint-employer theory relied on shared obligations stemming from the employment agreement with Nowhere Santa Monica.
BONUS. Nowhere Beverly Hills LLC operates the Erewhon organic products markets in Los Angeles. Erewhon is an anadrome derived from nowhere -- it is nowhere spelled backswards (almost, since the wh did not get reversed). Erewhon: Or, Over the Range, is also the title of Samuel Butler's 1872 novel about a satirical utopia.